I came here with a few questions, and wanted to read reactions. This is a new book and has not yet been widely reviewed.
I’m only partway through the book, which is highly readable and has a lot of information that is new to me. However I did catch a minor error in that the author calls Sherman a classmate from West Point, a bit of a stretch given that Sherman was a couple of years ahead of Grant.
This sort of minor error always makes me question more important assertions. I’m very interested in learning whether the research is generally solid.