IMHO we have one Black Confederate. A private.As I see it, these are two pages, dealing with the same man, Presley Hines.
Well, I will not pursue this as I have learned here that the question of "Black Confederates" always seems to open a can of worms. I don't intend to do that, but proof seems to be overwhelming to me. Thanks for telling that a small number of Black Confederates is conceded. That explains a lot!