51st Georgia
Private
- Joined
- May 31, 2011
- Location
- Miami FL
I have both books on the 1862 Shenandoah Valley campaign. I just purchased Campaign:Shenandoah from John Tiller Games and want to read about the battles.
i know Cozzens Shenandoah 1862 is far more balanced than Tanner‘s Stonewall in the Valleys mostly Confederate perspective but I also know Cozzens has been taken to task for his revisionist portrait of Stonewall.
i am a Jackson fan and have no problem though reading either. I’m more interested in the Confederate perspective anyway, but don’t want to give any better understanding by just defaulting to Tanner.
what say you all.. which is the better volume?
i know Cozzens Shenandoah 1862 is far more balanced than Tanner‘s Stonewall in the Valleys mostly Confederate perspective but I also know Cozzens has been taken to task for his revisionist portrait of Stonewall.
i am a Jackson fan and have no problem though reading either. I’m more interested in the Confederate perspective anyway, but don’t want to give any better understanding by just defaulting to Tanner.
what say you all.. which is the better volume?