Interesting list. It provokes the question, who won the post Civil War peace? The southern states won Jim Crow, an apartheid system. But the California big 4, Andrew Carnegie, and John D. Rockefeller one the peace, by one possible standard. Chicago seems to have won the post war growth contest. Missouri, freed from slavery, became another growth center. It attracted thousands of southerners taking a chance on a new start. Texas, after 1870, got its railroads, probably much sooner and much better than it would have as part of the Confederacy, had it survived.
And it European and Turkish history demonstrates, as bad as Jim Crow conditions were in some areas, the humanitarian disasters of the 20th century were largely avoided with respect to the freed people.
The US won. Based on the elimination of slavery, and the rapid capitalization of industry, the US became probably the most powerful nation in the world, for most of the 20th century. And southern states got to be part of that nation.