Not feeling the love for Bruce Catton


(Membership has it privileges! To remove this ad: Register NOW!)

Bee

Captain
Asst. Regtl. Quartermaster Gettysburg 2017
Joined
Dec 21, 2015
Messages
6,203
#8
It is amusing to me is often the same folks who poo-poo Catton gush over Shelby Foote (and vice versa). They are both essential CW reading. I do not place much weight on what forums say, as the opinions are often more on par with team fandom than historical analysis. Give Catton a shot and make your own decision.
 

gary

Captain
Joined
Feb 20, 2005
Messages
6,418
#10
It is amusing to me is often the same folks who poo-poo Catton gush over Shelby Foote (and vice versa). They are both essential CW reading. I do not place much weight on what forums say, as the opinions are often more on par with team fandom than historical analysis. Give Catton a shot and make your own decision.
Good comment Bee.

BTW, I tried to read Shelby Foote once. Gave up. It was just unappealing to me much like the way 7thWisconsin found "Grant Moves South."
 
Joined
Jan 10, 2016
Messages
249
#12
For me, Catton was my 'gateway drug' into the wider world of Civil War history. Particularly his Army of the Potomac trilogy and his American Heritage Civil War book.

I just find his writing style to be fantastic, very moving and engaging!

While I'm sure there are more detailed books with updated information out there, I still highly recommend Catton for a beginner to Civil War history.
 

Jamieva

1st Lieutenant
Joined
Feb 7, 2006
Messages
4,089
Location
Midlothian, VA
#13
I would be interested in the north/south breakdown of who read Catton and Foote. I grew up in Va...read Foote...never touched Catton. I think folks in the south had little interest in reading Catton because of the subject matter. I have acquired some of his lately and they are in my stack but I have not gotten to them.
 
Joined
Jan 10, 2016
Messages
249
#14
I would be interested in the north/south breakdown of who read Catton and Foote. I grew up in Va...read Foote...never touched Catton. I think folks in the south had little interest in reading Catton because of the subject matter. I have acquired some of his lately and they are in my stack but I have not gotten to them.
It could also be a generational thing? Catton completed publication of the Army of the Potomac trilogy in 1953 (as I recall) whereas Foote's trilogy wasn't completed until 1974.

I grew up in Canada and read (and thoroughly enjoyed) both.
 
Joined
Sep 28, 2013
Messages
13,036
Location
Mississippi
#15
Is he still worth reading?
I would say yeah . . . Catton is still worth a look during 2018.
He was required reading in one of my classes during the University days . . . eons ago.

However, I personally could not 'get into' his style of writing.
But that's just me.

You may enjoy his works.
 
Joined
Jul 13, 2018
Messages
360
Location
Bedford UK
#16
I am not great on the Generals and the Politics around the war - which, I believe, is people's gripe behind the Catton criticism - but for the story and experience of the common soldier, Catton and of course, Bell Wiley are first class.

If you haven't read the AOP series, you're really missing out. He tells the story of this often ill-served and disastrously-led Army superbly. His affection for and empathy for the average soldier of the Army of the Potomac is heart-warming. I had two copies each of Mr Lincoln's Army, Glory Road and A Stillness to Appomattox, one set being rather dog-eared because it was a lender to new recruits in our re-enactment group :thumbsup:
 

E_just_E

Brigadier General
Moderator
Joined
Sep 3, 2014
Messages
6,078
Location
Center Valley, PA
#17
I think that Catton is still worth reading. Same as Foote. I will probably put their work at similar level, despite the differences in perspective. It is story telling, and somewhat a Reader's Digest version of what happened without much detail, esp. in military tactics. I think that this is why some readers find it very rudimentary and also the reason that other readers just love it. It is approachable reading...
 

zburkett

First Sergeant
Joined
Aug 21, 2015
Messages
1,533
Location
Orange County, Virginia
#18
Catton (and Foote) both wrote widely read books that upped interest in the American Civil War that produced new levels of research. This new research dated some of what they had said. At the least they created thousands of people interested in the Civil War and history in general who were willing to do research. At the funniest they are victims of their own success.
 

Jimklag

Lt. Colonel
Silver Patron
Joined
Mar 3, 2017
Messages
9,911
Location
Chicagoland
#20
If you read the first chapter of the first volume of the AoP trilogy (Mr. Lincoln's Army), where Herman Haupt is trying to find soldiers to guard his train, you will be instantly hooked on Bruce Catton. No one, and I mean no one, wrote with the grace and style and pace of Bruce Catton in the entire Civil War library. IMHO, Catton is the gold standard of writers and I found no glaring historical errors in his books. If you want minute detail and minute-by-minute descriptions of battles, Catton is not your man. But, if you want beautifully written, well-researched history, give him a try.
 

Similar threads




(Membership has it privileges! To remove this ad: Register NOW!)
Top