Irish Immigrates Force Free Blacks Out...

Status
Not open for further replies.

5fish

Captain
Joined
Aug 26, 2007
Location
Central Florida
One of the untold stories of the Irish immigration to America is that they took the Free Blacks unskilled jobs within the cities like New York, Philadelphia and others... Yes, the Irish were displacing the local Free Blacks who many had been in these cities since the revolutionary days...

Ireland... https://www.theroot.com/the-divide-between-blacks-and-the-irish-1790878916

The Penal Laws regulated every aspect of Irish life and established Irish Catholics as an oppressed race.

On two occasions officials with judiciary authority in Ireland declared that "the law does not suppose any such person to exist as an Irish Roman Catholic."

Snip...

.As they came to the cities, they were crowded into districts that became centers of crime, vice and disease.

They commonly found themselves thrown together with free Negroes. Blacks and the Irish fought each other and the police, socialized and occasionally intermarried, and developed a common culture of the lowly.

In 1834 a mostly Irish mob in Philadelphia rampaged through the black district.
By the time they subsided, two black people were killed and many beaten. Two churches and upwards of 20 homes were laid waste, their contents looted or destroyed. A committee appointed to investigate the riot identified as a principal cause the belief that some employers were hiring black workers over whites.

Black workers had traditionally been an important part of the waterfront workforce in New York, Philadelphia and other northern cities, as well as Baltimore, Charleston, New Orleans and other Southern ports. In 1850, Irish laborers in New York demanded the dismissal of a black laborer who was working alongside them.

During the strike of 1852 and again in 1855, 1862 and 1863, Irish longshoremen battled black workers who had been brought in to take their places.

The underlying cause of the New York Riot of 1863, misnamed the Draft Riot, was the employment of black workers on the docks.

Snip...

"Irish gangs not only drove blacks out of jobs, they also served as surrogate unions."

In August 1862, a largely Irish mob in Brooklyn attacked the black employees, chiefly women and children, who were working in a tobacco factory

The mob, having driven the black employees to the upper stories of the building, then set fire to the first floor.

The factory was allowed to reopen only when the employer promised to dismiss the Negroes and hire Irish.

Snip... Irish pro-slavery...

Irish attitudes toward the free Negro in the North led them to oppose abolition.

In 1838 an Irish mob burned just-completed Pennsylvania Hall, built by subscription to serve as a center for abolitionist meetings. It was not that the Irish supported slavery:

They would have been happy to see slavery abolished, provided all the black folk could have been kept on the plantations or shipped out of the country altogether

The competition among Irish and black laborers failed to lead to unity because it did not take place under normal labor market conditions but was distorted by the color line.

As we see the Irish ruthlessly fought and push the Free Blacks out of thier position within the cities leading up to the Civil War... They share the same social class at first...


By 1841, about 100,000 Irish Catholic immigrants had flooded into the city, and this number soared in the wake of the Irish potato famine in 1846.

The blacks and Irish immigrants shared commonalities in terms of social status and economic standing and were thus forced to compete for the worst housing and lowest paying jobs in the city.

Evidently, they faced direct competition for jobs in labor market with the blacks. Resentment and hatred resulted from competition which escalated racial tension between these two groups. The Irish immigrants took the blacks' jobs away since they were willing to work for less money. In addition, the blacks took over Irish jobs when they went on strike. As a result, ethnic violence and gang activities increased. Civil disobedience spread throughout New York City, and later on led to the outbreak of the Draft Riots.
 
I going to add more insult to the Irish...

Link: http://ushistoryscene.com/article/nyc-draft-riots/

New York City entered an era of radical racial competition and gender reform that would last until the onset of World War I.

Although they later rioted against competition from black workers, in many cases, these immigrants had taken jobs from free blacks residing in the North. For decades, black men worked menial and lower-skill jobs for middling wages as “longshoremen…brick makers, whitewashers, coachmen, stablemen, porters, bootblacks, barbers, and waiters in hotels and restaurants,” while black women made up the majority of “domestic maids, cooks…laundresses and seamstresses.

Snip... Movies always make Five Points an Irish area...

The Five Points District, was a notorious multiethnic and immigrant-heavy Manhattan slum comprised of the five intersecting corners of than Anthony, Orange, and Cross streets.

It was a working-class neighborhood infamous for its gang violence, as depicted above in dramatized fashion. Many Irish immigrants settled here alongside poor free blacks.

As a result, many immigrants not only took the place of black laborers but also significantly drove down wages.


Free Blacks had communities being destroyed by the Irish wave...

Link:https://virtualny.ashp.cuny.edu/draftriots/Intro/draft_riot_intro_2.html

some as slaves, some as free people-- since well before the Revolutionary War. The city's African-American community grew during the first four decades of the nineteenth century, establishing and sustaining churches, newspapers, literary societies, and free schools. Black workers lived in close proximity to white workers in racially mixed communities that dotted the lower half of Manhattan

Working-class African Americans competed directly with immigrants, especially newly arrived Irish, for unskilled jobs, a competition that often turned ugly and violent in the years before the war.
 
Here how successful the Free Black of New York before the Irish immigrate washed up on our shores...


New York City has played a pivotal role in the history of black Americans. The city during the nineteenth century was a center of abolitionism, the site of influential black churches, benevolent organizations, and schools, and a focus of sometimes violent conflict between blacks and European immigrants. After the turn of the century Harlem became internationally known as a center of black nationalism and other forms of political activism, and of the literary and artistic movement known as the Harlem Renaissance. In later years the city's black community increased its political power and eventually accounted for more than a quarter of the total population.

Snip...

In 1821 the state legislature ruled that African-Americans could vote only if they owned property worth at least $250, while at the same time it eliminated the property qualification for white male voters. Not surprisingly there were only sixteen qualified African-American voters in 1825 and sixty-eight in 1835. Most employed African-Americans in the nineteenth century did unskilled work: men often were laborers and women domestic servants. In 1825 more than one fifth of the African-American residents of Manhattan lived in the slums of the sixth ward, which spread from the Five Points north and west to the Hudson River.

Snip...

Freedom's Journal, was launched in 1827 by the abolitionist minister Samuel Cornish and John Russwurm, one of the first blacks in the United States to receive a college degree. Its goal was to improve the political and economic standing of free blacks and agitate for the end of slavery. The newspaper later changed its name to Rights for All before ceasing publication in 1829. Other black newspapers in New York City in the nineteenth century were the Colored American (1837), the Ram's Horn, the Anglo-African (1859), and Frederick Douglass's North Star (1847). Williams helped to form the African Dorcas Society (1828), a women's sewing group that made clothing for young black students so that they could attend the African Free Schools. Many middle-class blacks opened restaurants, the most successful of which were Thomas Van Renesselaer's Eating House on Wall Street, Katy Ferguson's Pastry Shop on Thompson Street, Downing's Oyster House on Broad Street, and Cato's in lower Manhattan

Snip...

By 1850 most of the city's blacks were living in or near Greenwich Village, and by 1860 others had settled on the West Side between 10th and 30th streets, the infamous Tenderloin. After accounting for 5 percent of the city's population in 1840, blacks in 1860 accounted for less than 2 percent.

The link has more to read... https://virtualny.ashp.cuny.edu/EncyNYC/Blacks_for_draft_riots.html

 
Last edited:
Yep, Irish were Black replacements. Oh, I thought it was the Founding Fathers Vision Of Equality? Irish endured the same Racism the Black did, in the North. Eventually, the Irish becomes White by attacking the Colored.

 
Yep, Irish were Black replacements. Oh, I thought it was the Founding Fathers Vision Of Equality? Irish endured the same Racism the Black did, in the North. Eventually, the Irish becomes White by attacking the Colored.


I dont think their was an immigrant class that didn't suffer racism and segration coming to America, in St Louis for example had dago hill for Italians. kerry patch and dogtown for Irish, dutchtown for germans.

Not to mention anti Semitism and anti Catholicism was common as well......

 
Irish were Black replacements.
anti Catholicism

Philadephia the Irish rioted... even Nativist vs Catholics...

Link:https://philadelphiaencyclopedia.org/archive/riots-1830s-and-1840s/

The black population in Philadelphia and its surrounding suburbs more than doubled in the first three decades of the nineteenth century, from 6,880 in 1800 to 15,624 in 1830. Coinciding, but not caused by this growth, was the increase in the abolitionist movement.

On August 11, 1834, white and black citizens quarreled over seats on a merry-go-round known as the “flying horses” near Seventh and South Streets.

However, destruction continued over the next two days as white mobs tore down a black church in Southwark, sacked the First African Presbyterian Church, destroyed more than thirty black homes, and beat any black citizen in their path.

Minor skirmishes continued over the next few days, but Philadelphia’s first widespread race riot ended on August 14, 1834.

The political and jurisdiction fragmentation of the city and its surrounding districts did little to deflate or combat those tensions. Increased job competition among ethnic and racial groups, in particular between Irish and black workers, brought intermittent fighting that exploded into a full-scale riot in August 1842.

Explosive and destructive incidents of rioting occurred in multiple urban centers in the United States during the 1830s and 1840s
, including Boston, Baltimore, and Philadelphia.

Over the next two years the rise of Nativist and Protestant sentiment combined with the sharp increase in Irish Catholic immigration brought tensions to a fever pitch in the spring of 1844.
 
Yup.... another thing they won't teach you in school. They taught us plenty about Irish immigration, Italian immigration, Ellis Island, etc. But always in a happy positive way, never touch much on how they were treated after getting here, just like we don't teach how African-Americans were treated after being freed.

I had to learn from my grandparents and great-aunts/uncles how my Italian family was treated on arrival. Many of them immigrated at a young age, the rest were the first to be born on US soil.
 
One of the untold stories of the Irish immigration to America is that they took the Free Blacks unskilled jobs within the cities like New York, Philadelphia and others... Yes, the Irish were displacing the local Free Blacks who many had been in these cities since the revolutionary days...

Ireland... https://www.theroot.com/the-divide-between-blacks-and-the-irish-1790878916

The Penal Laws regulated every aspect of Irish life and established Irish Catholics as an oppressed race.

On two occasions officials with judiciary authority in Ireland declared that "the law does not suppose any such person to exist as an Irish Roman Catholic."

Snip...

.As they came to the cities, they were crowded into districts that became centers of crime, vice and disease.

They commonly found themselves thrown together with free Negroes. Blacks and the Irish fought each other and the police, socialized and occasionally intermarried, and developed a common culture of the lowly.

In 1834 a mostly Irish mob in Philadelphia rampaged through the black district.
By the time they subsided, two black people were killed and many beaten. Two churches and upwards of 20 homes were laid waste, their contents looted or destroyed. A committee appointed to investigate the riot identified as a principal cause the belief that some employers were hiring black workers over whites.

Black workers had traditionally been an important part of the waterfront workforce in New York, Philadelphia and other northern cities, as well as Baltimore, Charleston, New Orleans and other Southern ports. In 1850, Irish laborers in New York demanded the dismissal of a black laborer who was working alongside them.

During the strike of 1852 and again in 1855, 1862 and 1863, Irish longshoremen battled black workers who had been brought in to take their places.

The underlying cause of the New York Riot of 1863, misnamed the Draft Riot, was the employment of black workers on the docks.

Snip...

"Irish gangs not only drove blacks out of jobs, they also served as surrogate unions."

In August 1862, a largely Irish mob in Brooklyn attacked the black employees, chiefly women and children, who were working in a tobacco factory

The mob, having driven the black employees to the upper stories of the building, then set fire to the first floor.

The factory was allowed to reopen only when the employer promised to dismiss the Negroes and hire Irish.

Snip... Irish pro-slavery...

Irish attitudes toward the free Negro in the North led them to oppose abolition.

In 1838 an Irish mob burned just-completed Pennsylvania Hall, built by subscription to serve as a center for abolitionist meetings. It was not that the Irish supported slavery:

They would have been happy to see slavery abolished, provided all the black folk could have been kept on the plantations or shipped out of the country altogether

The competition among Irish and black laborers failed to lead to unity because it did not take place under normal labor market conditions but was distorted by the color line.

As we see the Irish ruthlessly fought and push the Free Blacks out of thier position within the cities leading up to the Civil War... They share the same social class at first...


By 1841, about 100,000 Irish Catholic immigrants had flooded into the city, and this number soared in the wake of the Irish potato famine in 1846.

The blacks and Irish immigrants shared commonalities in terms of social status and economic standing and were thus forced to compete for the worst housing and lowest paying jobs in the city.

Evidently, they faced direct competition for jobs in labor market with the blacks. Resentment and hatred resulted from competition which escalated racial tension between these two groups. The Irish immigrants took the blacks' jobs away since they were willing to work for less money. In addition, the blacks took over Irish jobs when they went on strike. As a result, ethnic violence and gang activities increased. Civil disobedience spread throughout New York City, and later on led to the outbreak of the Draft Riots.

Irish-Black conflict over waterfront jobs in NYC has been extensively documented but it's quite a stretch to day that the conflict caused the widespread NYC rioting of July 1863, or that the Draft Riot was "misnamed."

The NYC riot erupted on the day that the draft lottery was to be conducted, and lottery offices were specifically targeted by mobs. Riots took place in numerous neighborhoods, including some where no blacks lived or worked. The rioting was caused by the draft and anti-war sentiment: The free blacks of NYC were collateral damage, not the cause.
 
Last edited:
In Detroit riots 1863... fanned by a paper...

From wiki...

The City Council was dominated by Democrats, and many of the Irish and German immigrants belonged to that party. The Detroit Free Press was a Democratic Party paper that was opposed to President Abraham Lincoln's conduct of the American Civil War and its increasing demand for recruits. The newspaper advocated **** and was pro-labor.[2] In the months leading up to the riot, the newspaper frequently published articles connecting "blacks to labor problems, blacks to citizenship issues, blacks to the war, and blacks to crime and general degradation of the moral order", stressing how they were a threat to working-class white men and their limited power.[2] Following the Emancipation Proclamation of January 1863, the newspaper published articles that frequently opposed the interests of white labor and blacks

Snip... spark ...

A mixed-race man, William Faulkner, was arrested for allegedly molesting a young white girl, and tried in court. (The two girls whose testimony was critical to his arrest both recanted their stories years later.) Although Faulkner had voted regularly (a privilege reserved to whites) and identified as Spanish-Indian, both newspapers described him as "negro", and that was how the whites came to regard him.[2]

Snip...

Survivors said the mob attacked black businesses and houses, looting them of anything valuable, and stealing from the residents. The whites eventually moved beyond the black area into poor white areas, continuing the destruction. Some blacks fled the area, going across the Detroit River to Canada or west to what was then the independent community of Corktown. The city finally ordered in troops from Ypsilanti and Fort Wayne, and by 11 p.m. had suppressed the violence. More than 200 blacks and some whites had lost their homes to the destruction. There was an estimated $15,000 to 20,000 in property damage, mostly suffered by blacks.[2]

Snip... end...

Faulkner was convicted and sentenced to prison for life. Several years later, the two girls who testified against him recanted their story, and Faulkner was pardoned. He returned to Detroit, where some white businessmen helped him start a produce business.[3]
 
Irish-Black conflict over waterfront jobs in NYC has been extensively documented but it's quite a stretch to day that the conflict caused the extensive NYC rioting of July 1863, or that the Draft Riot was "misnamed."

The NYC riot erupted on the day that the draft lottery was to be conducted, and lottery offices were specifically targeted by mobs. Riots took place in numerous neighborhoods, including some where no blacks lived or worked. The rioting was caused by the draft and anti-war sentiment. The free blacks of NYC were collateral damage, not the cause.

f

Who were the ones. Left Hanging. The hatred of Blacks didn’t just begin that Day.

Clearly the Irish had no justification for fighting for Black Emancipation.
 
Philadephia the Irish rioted... even Nativist vs Catholics...

Link:https://philadelphiaencyclopedia.org/archive/riots-1830s-and-1840s/

The black population in Philadelphia and its surrounding suburbs more than doubled in the first three decades of the nineteenth century, from 6,880 in 1800 to 15,624 in 1830. Coinciding, but not caused by this growth, was the increase in the abolitionist movement.

On August 11, 1834, white and black citizens quarreled over seats on a merry-go-round known as the “flying horses” near Seventh and South Streets.

However, destruction continued over the next two days as white mobs tore down a black church in Southwark, sacked the First African Presbyterian Church, destroyed more than thirty black homes, and beat any black citizen in their path.

Minor skirmishes continued over the next few days, but Philadelphia’s first widespread race riot ended on August 14, 1834.

The political and jurisdiction fragmentation of the city and its surrounding districts did little to deflate or combat those tensions. Increased job competition among ethnic and racial groups, in particular between Irish and black workers, brought intermittent fighting that exploded into a full-scale riot in August 1842.

Explosive and destructive incidents of rioting occurred in multiple urban centers in the United States during the 1830s and 1840s
, including Boston, Baltimore, and Philadelphia.

Over the next two years the rise of Nativist and Protestant sentiment combined with the sharp increase in Irish Catholic immigration brought tensions to a fever pitch in the spring of 1844.

Fever pitch didn’t stop in 44. Nativist became a part of the Republican Party which created a United North. Republicans convinced the Yankee, Southerners were a bigger threat to them than the Yankee. 2nd Founding of the KKK also attacked these UnAmericans.
 
Fear of large numbers of freed blacks coming north to compete for unskilled jobs was perhaps the principal factor in Irish-American opposition to the war and support of the Democratic party. It was the root cause of extreme anti-black feelings among the immigrant Irish. The less privileged always most fear those who are economically just "below" them -- they are the most dangerous competition for jobs, because they are often willing to work harder for less pay. And, with the draft taking many Irish away from those jobs, blacks would have a still greater opportunity to take them. This has been known and understood for decades, indeed, right from the start. It's what I was taught in school 60 years ago, and not a new revelation -- why are we acting so surprised?
 
Last edited:
Fear of large numbers of freed blacks coming north to compete for unskilled jobs was perhaps the principal factor in Irish-American opposition to the war and support of the Democratic opposition. It was the root cause of extreme anti-black feelings among the immigrant Irish. The less privileged always most fear those who are economically just "below" them -- they are the most dangerous competition for jobs, because they are often willing to work harder for less pay. And, with the draft taking many Irish away from those jobs, blacks would have a still greater opportunity to take them. This has been known and understood for decades, indeed, right from the start. It's not a new revelation -- why are we acting so surprised?

I agree anti immigrant racism and segregation, as well as anti Semitism and anti Catholic sentiment has been known for decades.... not only European immigrants suffered from it, but obviously Hispanic, Asian, and Native Americans is also well documented........however I can see why its a surprise to some, because its largely overlooked and not mentioned in discussions of racism in the history of United States
 
I agree anti immigrant racism and segregation, as well as anti Semitism and anti Catholic sentiment has been known for decades.... not only European immigrants suffered from it, but obviously Hispanic, Asian, and Native Americans is also well documented........however I can see why its a surprise to some, because its largely overlooked and not mentioned in discussions of racism in the history of United States

Some don’t enjoy researching Northern History. Some Deny this History, because it doesn’t fit the Narrative of the North fighting for Equality. All part of Northern Nationalism which measures the North against the Racist, Slave Holding South. If the North, is the Antithetical of the South, how could they do these things?
 
Some don’t enjoy researching Northern History. Some Deny this History, because it doesn’t fit the Narrative of the North fighting for Equality. All part of Northern Nationalism which measures the North against the Racist, Slave Holding South. If the North, is the Antithetical of the South, how could they do these things?
Any "some people" who make such claims are idiots, and not worth listening to. Your likening that "some people" to any segment of this forum, or to more than an extreme, uninformed minority of northern opinion in general is ridiculous and insulting.
 
Philadephia the Irish rioted... even Nativist vs Catholics...

Link:https://philadelphiaencyclopedia.org/archive/riots-1830s-and-1840s/

See also

"HUNTING THE NIGS" IN PHILADELPHIA: THE RACE RIOT OF AUGUST 1834
John Runcie
Pennsylvania History: A Journal of Mid-Atlantic Studies
Vol. 39, No. 2 (APRIL, 1972), pp. 187-218

 
The Irish keep on giving but how have they been able to escape their past behavior towards Free Blacks of the North...

So far as far back as 1829 in Cincinnati the Irish lead another riot against the local Free black community with one purpose to drive them from the city...

Racism and economic tensions fulminated in Cincinnati, Ohio in August of 1829, resulting in white violence against African Americans over a two-week period in August 17-22.

White mobs estimated at times at 200 to 300 led by Irish immigrants invaded the riverfront area where African Americans lived with the avowed intent to drive them all out of the city.

A number of them emigrated to Canada to a community they named Wilberforce. Those who stayed behind attempted to rebuild their lives but experienced further white assaults in 1836 and beyond.

Causes for the violence were rooted in racial animus exacerbated by competition for jobs.
Free blacks and increasing numbers of African Americans who had escaped slavery in the South arrived in Cincinnati with hopes of safety and economic opportunity.


Snip... the article goes into how the Free Blacks were not welcome in Ohio and passed laws trying to limit their immigration... These laws were the pretext for the riot...

Cincinnati whites expressed alarm at the growth of the black population in the city, especially those deemed indigent. City leaders invoked the Black Act of 1807, a state law which had been installed to limit African American migration into Ohio

However, on June 30, the Cincinnati Daily Gazette printed a notice warning that the city would rigidly enforce the Black Act of 1807 within 30 days: all black residents must enter into bond by that time or face expulsion.

Nevertheless, from the night of August 15 through August 22, white mobs estimated at up to 300 people rioted in the Fourth Ward, where the majority of the city’s 2,250 African Americans lived. The mob destroyed businesses, burned residences and other structures, and assaulted black residents.


Do the Irish have any more race riots they lead and took part in... Hummm...
 
Although this might come as a shock for some, there is no valid basis to compare Black Africans' true plight and that of poor white immigrants from Ireland or elsewhere at any point in history. Despite horrific conditions of passage to a New World for both groups, their positions were vastly different before and after arrival. Irish flight was volitional to ensure bare survival as their homeland was hit by famine and nutritional blight; Africans were violently stolen for lifelong forced labor far away from all they had known before then.

And no doubt whatsoever exists about indentured servants' lot as a tough one that often included abuse, unwilling political imprisonment or even young children. In fact, I read an ex-slave narrative account of white youth abducted or sold by worthless parents as slaves with light skin. Another well-kept dirty secret holds Irish women laborers forced to mate with Black male captives to create a new mulatto slave "breed" of high market value.

But other facts remain true that forever negate the two groups ever sharing the same position. Irish refugees were voluntary escapees vs. abductees marched hundreds of miles to ships that lie in wait and forced into a noxious hold for to auction blocks and sold to highest bidders among societies that denied them basic protections. Irish children belonged to parents, not slaveholders free to sell, rape or beat them to death with no legal risk whatsoever. By contrast, white indentured servants were legally recognized as humans who entered voluntary contracts of finite duration that did NOT impute any obligation to descendants for perpetuity. So, the poorest Irish contract workers enjoyed liberty to pursue education or wealth accumulation that Negro chattel "property" was denied by law. Modern Irish folklore dubs ancestral status as slaves but the term had a distinct legal connotation that excluded Europeans by definition.

Despite this, widespread fiction, myths and outright lies persist to date that ****s perpetrate about nonexistent Irish slavery.

00xp-irishslaves-1-jumbo.jpg

This image cropped from an 1884 Roman slave market painting is used to illustrate articles that make a false claim that Irish people were slaves in colonial America.

17irish3_xp-jumbo.jpg

This version of the meme is 1911 photo of child laborers in a PA mine used to illustrate false claims of Irish slavery.

00xp-irishslaves-2-jumbo.jpg


This article on a possible movie about Irish slaves is illustrated by a 1913 photo of child laborers on a TX farm.​

And so the lies go on ad infinitum, ad nauseam...

No wonder reliable sources say otherwise, who include reputable Irish and Black contemporary historians alike.
 
Some don’t enjoy researching Northern History. Some Deny this History, because it doesn’t fit the Narrative of the North fighting for Equality. All part of Northern Nationalism which measures the North against the Racist, Slave Holding South. If the North, is the Antithetical of the South, how could they do these things?

Sorry but try as you might, you will never equalize racism suffered in the North or the South at the same level as the institution of slavery that the Southern states attempted to perpetuate and expand until its ending in 1865.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top