Frozen Death

dawna

First Sergeant
Joined
Feb 20, 2005
Location
canada
Expired Image Removed

With the slaughter of so many soldiers on the battlefields during the Civil War, there came a very unusual phenomenon referred to as "Frozen Death," which became more apparent after the Battle of Antietam. In one example, members of one Union infantry regiment saw in the near distance a Confederate cavalry soldier mounted on his horse. The horseman, silent, sat erect in the saddle, holding his rifle in his right hand, and holding the horse's mane in his left. As the Union soldiers came nearer, they called out to him, demanding his surrender.

No response was heard from the Rebel. As they came even closer, the Rebel soldiers head was turned in their direction as if he was watching them approach. When the Union soldiers came directly upon him, they observed that he was dead, frozen in the exact position he had held when he was instantaneously killed by a bullet that struck him in the right temple.

Learning of the many reports similar to this, surgeon John Brinton was ordered to go to Antietam, on the day after the battle, and collect information about these strange reports. Brinton observed many soldiers in this "frozen state," at the Cornfield and Bloody Lane. In his study and report, Brinton said that these positions were not caused by rigor mortis. He continued, saying, "These attitudes, were not those of the relaxations of death, but were rather, of a seemingly active character, dependent apparently upon a final muscular action at the last moment of life, in the spasm of which the muscles set and remained rigid and inflexible." In a further study, Brinton, observed a Rebel soldier found half kneeling behind a fence, his head erect with one hand on a fence rail. Brinton continued by saying that this soldier had evidently been killed while loading his rifle, and in the act of rising to his feet, was shot by a ball that passed directly through the center of his head, and emerged posteriorly. In another example of "Frozen Death," at another location, Brinton observed a railroad brakeman who had been shot between the eyes. According to Brinton, this man was killed instantly, and his body froze in a fixed position, with his arms extended and stiff on the handwheel of the brake. The pipe that he was smoking remained tightly gripped between his teeth.

Brinton continued to study this phenomenon, and became an authority on the subject. He published his observations in 1870 in the "American Journal of the Medical Services."


"About Famous People,"
John T. Marck
 
I don't believe that I've read about that phenomena before and it's very interesting. Many thanks for posting it Dawna!
 
A neuropsych colleague suggested that they were decorticated when I asked her about a similar incident observed by the 5th NC Cavalry at Brandy Station in '63. I looked it up, and sure enough, there is a position that people freeze in that's pretty consistent with the posture of a horseback rider.
 
A neuropsych colleague suggested that they were decorticated when I asked her about a similar incident observed by the 5th NC Cavalry at Brandy Station in '63. I looked it up, and sure enough, there is a position that people freeze in that's pretty consistent with the posture of a horseback rider.

Another one of those strange and interesting facts of the Civil War.

Mulejack
 
Another fascinating fact the 8th grade will ooh and ahh over. Thank you. These are real attention grabbers and are totally invaluable to get them to pay attention through the not so cool stuff!
 
That's fascinating stuff, Dawna! I'm a volunteer at both Antietam and the National Museum of Civil War Medicine and I'd love to have that information to pass along--is it available in printed format? Thanks!
 
Virginia S. Wood said:
A neuropsych colleague suggested that they were decorticated when I asked her about a similar incident observed by the 5th NC Cavalry at Brandy Station in '63. I looked it up, and sure enough, there is a position that people freeze in that's pretty consistent with the posture of a horseback rider.

That would explain other images of dead at Antietam where the legs are drawn upwards and flayed outward so that it appears the body was contracting after death.

Phillip M Bryant, author blog
 
Fascinating! You know, animals do that as well when they die instantly. Dr John Brinton wouldn't be related to George Brinton McClellan, would he?

Odd things were discovered during our CW - De Costa Syndrome was another, which is now called PTSD. I think it may have been noticed in soldiers before but the large numbers of our vets having it made it really obvious!
 
Expired Image Removed

With the slaughter of so many soldiers on the battlefields during the Civil War, there came a very unusual phenomenon referred to as "Frozen Death," which became more apparent after the Battle of Antietam. In one example, members of one Union infantry regiment saw in the near distance a Confederate cavalry soldier mounted on his horse. The horseman, silent, sat erect in the saddle, holding his rifle in his right hand, and holding the horse's mane in his left. As the Union soldiers came nearer, they called out to him, demanding his surrender.

No response was heard from the Rebel. As they came even closer, the Rebel soldiers head was turned in their direction as if he was watching them approach. When the Union soldiers came directly upon him, they observed that he was dead, frozen in the exact position he had held when he was instantaneously killed by a bullet that struck him in the right temple.

Learning of the many reports similar to this, surgeon John Brinton was ordered to go to Antietam, on the day after the battle, and collect information about these strange reports. Brinton observed many soldiers in this "frozen state," at the Cornfield and Bloody Lane. In his study and report, Brinton said that these positions were not caused by rigor mortis. He continued, saying, "These attitudes, were not those of the relaxations of death, but were rather, of a seemingly active character, dependent apparently upon a final muscular action at the last moment of life, in the spasm of which the muscles set and remained rigid and inflexible." In a further study, Brinton, observed a Rebel soldier found half kneeling behind a fence, his head erect with one hand on a fence rail. Brinton continued by saying that this soldier had evidently been killed while loading his rifle, and in the act of rising to his feet, was shot by a ball that passed directly through the center of his head, and emerged posteriorly. In another example of "Frozen Death," at another location, Brinton observed a railroad brakeman who had been shot between the eyes. According to Brinton, this man was killed instantly, and his body froze in a fixed position, with his arms extended and stiff on the handwheel of the brake. The pipe that he was smoking remained tightly gripped between his teeth.

Brinton continued to study this phenomenon, and became an authority on the subject. He published his observations in 1870 in the "American Journal of the Medical Services."


"About Famous People,"
John T. Marck
interesting post,what happened to the horse the soldier was sitting on in the first paragraph?
 
Fascinating. I didn't know it was common. The only instance I was familiar with was the Confederate general AND his horse that assumed a frozen position astride the yankee breastworks at Franklin when they were killed. His name escapes me, another senior moment.
 
Shelby Foote told a story of a soldier at Spotsylvania killed instantly whose hand froze outstretched and faced up - his buddies used it to set their ammo on...

Incidentally, did a little research on Dr Brinton. He is indeed related to McClellan - first cousin - and was later in the war Grant's personal physician. He also helped found the famous if bizarre Mutter Museum!
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top