- Joined
- Aug 25, 2012
It would appear that in the far west there was limited opportunity for Confederacy success. Was there any real chance for the Confederacy in the far west? I am not sure a difference commander would have made a real difference.
Can you be more specific?It would appear that in the far west there was limited opportunity for Confederacy success. Was there any real chance for the Confederacy in the far west? I am not sure a difference commander would have made a real difference.
A different commander could have made the difference. It all actually boiled down to their supply train being destroyed. Once that happened there was no hope. So if they could have avoided that event there is a possibility of some success. Could they have gone to the Pacific Ocean with their Confederacy? I don't see the numbers of troops available to hold all that territory.It would appear that in the far west there was limited opportunity for Confederacy success. Was there any real chance for the Confederacy in the far west? I am not sure a difference commander would have made a real difference.
I think Green pretty much did command Sibley's force De facto. De facto da matter that Sibley's was drunk all the time.I don't think commanders like Shelby and Marmaduke were the problem. Certainly not Taylor. Had Green commanded the Sibley force, who knows how it would have turned out. When cavalry enlistees had to bring everything they needed on their own- weapons, horses, clothes, saddles, blankets- it is obvious where the problem existed. Just my 2 cents.
Maybe Sibley was lucid enough at times to make some bad decisions. LolI think Green pretty much did command Sibley's force De facto. De facto da matter that Sibley's was drunk all the time.
If they set realistic goals, maybe. It didn't happen that way. They were also badly out numbered.The Confederacy hoped to take Southern California or Colorado, but I am not sure they had the military forces or logistics to do so. Both places would have put a real strain on the available supply lines. I would have to research the available man power available to the Union and the Confederacy in the far west.