Can a town be period inaccurate?

[major bill]

So what about this "town"?

 

[archieclement]

Looks pretty modern based on the red wagon

 

[7thWisconsin]

LOL. That is pretty funny out of context. I can understand the need for civilian reenactors to have homes, buildings, etc to anchor their impression around, but it seems to me that this one tried too hard about half the time, and not enough the other half. Maybe the civilian equivalent of fighting for the park playground. (Btw, valuable advice: every reenactor should attend at least one event as a spectator. It's a sobering experience.)

 

[zburkett]

That looks like a work in progress. I like it that they are making the effort.

 

[Patrick H]

Doesn't work for me.

 

[thomas aagaard]

When we are talking pre fabricated, none permanent houses for reenactment/live roleplay I have seen better...

Small medieval-ish town with 200 people living in it...
From 2004: Houses build of wood poles and cloth. (note the church in the middle)

From 2012 - 320 people... Now All houses are of wood and can be stored in 40foot containers, and everything is pulled down in a few hours.

 

[major bill]

LOL. That is pretty funny out of context. I can understand the need for civilian reenactors to have homes, buildings, etc to anchor their impression around, but it seems to me that this one tried too hard about half the time, and not enough the other half. Maybe the civilian equivalent of fighting for the park playground. (Btw, valuable advice: every reenactor should attend at least one event as a spectator. It's a sobering experience.)

So it is a farb town?

 

[jackt62]

The reenactments I have been too rely solely on tents, for sutlers, medical, etc. etc. I don't see a need for anything beyond that.

 

[major bill]

A tent for a courthouse? Well this did give the civilian reenactors a place to hang out. This reenacted has moved and now has a park that has a town with real buildings.

 

[Seduzal]

Thanks for sharing this interesting, The now and then photos..

 

[zburkett]

The Civil War did take place in more than open fields.

 

[archieclement]

The Civil War did take place in more than open fields.

I always found it amusing that the local reenactment has the MSG camping with CW tents ect…...Most local accounts have em sleeping in barns with farmers bringing em food.

My uncle had a barn where MSG or guerrillas had carved a checkerboard on a beam that they used kernels' of corn to play. They found 6 pdr cannonballs in the field of the same farm.

 

[Virginia Dave]

A tent for a courthouse? Well this did give the civilian reenactors a place to hang out. This reenacted has moved and now has a park that has a town with real buildings.

where is it located?

 

[major bill]

At Jackson Michigan at the Cascades Park. One year they had a house of "working girls" in this fake town. I am not sure all visitors like women lounging around in their nether wear.

 

[archieclement]

At Jackson Michigan at the Cascades Park. One year they had a house of "working girls" in this fake town. I am not sure all visitors like women lounging around in their nether wear.

On the other hand some of us aren't easily offended and have a high tolerance for such things

 

[major bill]

On the other hand some of us aren't easily offended and have a high tolerance for such things

The "working girls" did hoot, holler, and call for customers a bit.

They did not reenact the next year.

 

[archieclement]

The "working girls" did hoot, holler, and call for customers a bit.

They did not reenact the next year.

Wonder how without a house of ill repute they account for "Among white Union soldiers there was a total of 73,382 syphilis cases and 109,397 gonorrhea cases."?

 

[captaindrew]

If there is a period correct town for a reenactment it's this one https://civilwartalk.com/threads/a-...ry-village-in-mumford-ny-last-weekend.148247/ One of if not my favorite event of the year.

 

[JOHN42768]

Straight form Disney's "Imagination Land". Complete with Snake Oil salesman

 

[Yellowhammer_Possum]

Shaker Village in Kentucky is a great "authentic" town.

I also really liked the "houses" at the Bummer's event several years ago. They made for good burning. Even though I was Georgia Militia for the event.