I have to agree. I hadn't seen North & South when I voted for G&G but it's way better than I thought. It reminds me of Gettysburg.Edit: Just decided to watch the North & South version of it on youtube. I like just how grimy and dirty this portrayal of the battle is. Much more battle like than any of the others. What keeps it from not being the best is by having the US 1st Sharpshooter regiment being there. They weren't raised until later but it's far more realistic I think of just combat in general of this period than any of the others.