I read it - thank you for posting. Two things of notice - Longstreet's "Professional Ethics" were lacking, throughout the war, generally, in terms of his willlingness to follow orders in "good faith" - without question. I relate to being told what to do, when any thinking person should know better, but I'm not a soldier. He also ordered a bad charge against Burnside at Knoxville and gets "dinged" for it in the evaluation. But, he recognized the error and called the thing off. Burnside did not recognize his own error at Fredricksburg, to put it mildly.
It's a pretty good evaluation, with a bit of "strategery" thrown in for good measure. Thanks again for posting.