PDA

View Full Version : Civil War History - "What if..." Discussions

  1. Lee & Grant meet at Chattanooga---What if-
  2. Four day start for Lee--What if--
  3. What if the weather had been normal
  4. Sherman dies Nov. 15, 1864, What then--
  5. Thomas Takes Command
  6. The Gandhi Way.."What if"
  7. French 75mm with Lee at Gettysburg--
  8. What If The South Had Won? A Video Reenactment!
  9. What if Lee had made it into North Carolina?
  10. What if the federals never found the cigar-wrapping document?
  11. Hood merges with Lee...."What if"
  12. Lee sacrifices Petersburg...moves north "What if"
  13. Jackson and McLaws killed at Antietam
  14. Gel'in
  15. Invasion of Pennsylvania Whatif
  16. Lt. General position never was?..What if..
  17. Pres. Johnson Dies 1866-What if??
  18. Gen. Pemberton had abandon Vicksburg??
  19. What if Gen, Hood had not fallen at Gettysburg..
  20. What if New York joined the Confederacy?
  21. What if "Stonewall" Jackson had survived the war and served with Lee
  22. What if Early....
  23. What if Gettysburg started on the 30th???
  24. What if Lee had Nukes??
  25. What if Lee decided not to fight?
  26. Lee's invasion is successful. What next?
  27. What if R.E. Lee had joined Virginia
  28. What if all the former US Military Officers remained loyal to the Union?
  29. Roscrans captures AOT at Tullahoma
  30. What would Beauregard have done.....?
  31. What if Granger goes to Chattanooga ...
  32. What If.... The Trial Of Jefferson Davis
  33. What if Lincoln Had Been Kidnapped?
  34. What if Gen. Morgan had executed US Provost Marshals during his First Kentucky Raid?
  35. What if Mexico Allied with the Confederacy?
  36. What Would Lee have Done Next---?
  37. Jackson at Chattanooga
  38. An early end to the war
  39. The erring sisters go in peace
  40. What if N. B. Forrest was attached to J . E. Johnston's army in 1864?
  41. Lee Killed at Chancellorsville......
  42. Joe Johnston instead of Beauregard
  43. What if Grant had commanded the AOT
  44. What if Hood had not invaded Tennessee?
  45. What if Lee had won at Chancellorsville
  46. Grant gets commision in the AotP
  47. Lee/Grant--North Anna, What if?
  48. What if Gen. Lee had another.........
  49. Hooker in Charge
  50. Can you hear me now?
  51. What if Lee had won...by Winston Churchill
  52. Jeb Stuart's death
  53. Lee out West after Chancellorsville?
  54. What if Gen. Longstreet had gone West in the Spring of 1863?
  55. Alamo What if???
  56. What if the CSA had aggressivley pursued a Guerrilla Campaign against the Union?
  57. Mud in Middle Tennessee
  58. What if the CSA had re-inforced Gen. Sterling Price at Lexington, MO?
  59. "Confederate Gold found in DC!"
  60. France/Mexico
  61. What if Seven Pines had gone the other way?
  62. A Two-Term Henry Clay Presidency
  63. What if...Grant Won the Race to Spotsylvania?
  64. If Meade Did destroy the ANV after Gettysburg
  65. If Sherman Ran, Served .........
  66. If Grant commanded the Army of the Potomac at Gettysburg...
  67. Jeb Stuart during the invasion
  68. No King Cotton
  69. Southern Victory at Gettysburg: Aftermath
  70. John Hunt Morgan
  71. CW Sldr thoughts on ACU's
  72. Nashville WAS defended?
  73. General John Bell Hood Killed!
  74. If the CSA had succeeded?
  75. Thomas in command of the Army Of The Potomac
  76. After Appomattox?
  77. What if Lee's Army was destroyed at Antietam?
  78. What if A. P. Hill's Light Division had bicycles at Antietam?
  79. What If books
  80. What if Hood's Tennessee Campaign had been successful?
  81. Wild What_If
  82. What if..Grant had not been with Meade
  83. Jackson's night attack at Chancellorsville
  84. Joe Johnston
  85. MG C.F. Smith
  86. John Wilder
  87. Who else but Lincoln?
  88. Could Have Wilson Beaten Forrest...
  89. No. 3 Same Scenerio
  90. No. 2 - Same scenerio
  91. Recreated battle scenerio
  92. Hardee replaces Johnston
  93. ...Lincoln had not been murdered?
  94. Alternate History
  95. Did Stonewall Jackson Get it Right?
  96. Cleburne in Control
  97. Athens Alabama September 23, 1864
  98. Could Lee have won a decisive victory over Grant in The Wilderness
  99. What if Grant Gave Lee the Slip May 4th 1864
  100. What if Longstreet Took Command From Bragg in 1863?
  101. Civil War People
  102. Book Title
  103. D.H. Hill leading 2nd corps ???
  104. what If Albert Sydney Johnston survived Shiloh?
  105. One for the books...
  106. Jackson vs Sheridan
  107. What if Lee had remained a U.S. Army officer?
  108. If the Union Army had Breachloaders in 1862
  109. What if the Confederacy....
  110. If you had the power
  111. Reenacting Illeagle?
  112. Thomas and Sherman
  113. Chickamauga-what if
  114. What if the Confederacy fought a true defensive war?
  115. Without slavery, do we have a Civil War???
  116. Logistics and Gettysburg
  117. What if they 'switched' presidents?
  118. What If Kentucky had become Confederate?
  119. What really happened to Pres. Jeff Davis' adminstration after the war
  120. What ifs...
  121. New York City secession
  122. What If England Had Cut Off Saltpeter Supply
  123. What if Albert Sydney Johnston...
  124. Peninsula Campaign
  125. The Duel to end the war
  126. What if R. E. Lee had...
  127. What if General Thomas had...
  128. What if N. B. Forrest was killed at Ft. Donnelson?
  129. What if California had a beef with the Feds about some "States rights" issue
  130. What if Lt General Scott did not resign in Nov. 1861?
  131. The fall of Washington
  132. What if Gen Lee had accepted Pres Lincoln's offer to Command the Union Troops?
  133. New Orleans
  134. Trent affiair becoming an actual war, potential Irish Home Rule 1864?
  135. What if John Brown had succeeded at Harper's Ferry?
  136. Ideal CSA President?
  137. Nashville as capital?
  138. Would restriction have finished slavery?
  139. What if Lee hadn't lost the Special Order No. 191?
  140. Was McClellan largely responsible for the reverses the Union suffered up to sept 1862
  141. Hancock Commander AOP late June 1863
  142. What About English Or French Aid For Csa?
  143. Sherman instead of Meade
  144. What if ... help greatly needed
  145. Beuragard instead of Hood
  146. What if Texas had stayed in the Union?
  147. What if Gen. Jackson lived.
  148. If Confederate capital was not moved to Richmond, Va. from Montgomery, Al.?
  149. What if John Breckenridge was elected as President of the Confederacy?
  150. What if Lee chose to keep fighting?
  151. Shiloh-Grant's Last Line
  152. What if the Confederacy had been formed by the Southern colonies in 1787?
  153. Forrest lost a Brigade and was transferred
  154. What if Burnsides
  155. What If Lincoln Had Ben Assassinated Sooner?
  156. Gettysburg day 2
  157. What If Longstreet Had Gotten Command Of The ANV?
  158. What if Stuart had been at Gettysburg earlier?
  159. What if Lincoln had not been assassinated?
  160. Longtreet stays with the AoT?
  161. You are in command at Franklin.
  162. what if jackson had been in command at culps hill
  163. what if Zach Taylor had not died in office?
  164. What if you could spend an afternoon....
  165. What if Hooker hadn't been stunned at Chancellorsville?
  166. Dream Brigade,Division & Corps
  167. What if Ft. Sumter had not been fired upon?
  168. R.E. Lee...Union General
  169. Aftermath
  170. What if Fremont had won the 1856 elections?
  171. Sickles and Hazel Grove (may 3, 1863)
  172. What if the Confederates captured the Union army at Chatanooga
  173. The South won the war and...
  174. What would you do?
  175. What if Jackson was alive during the Overland campaign
  176. What if Jackson went on to Washington
  177. What if Lee led the Army of Tennessee?
  178. What if Lee has accepted command of the AOP
  179. What if John Ripley wasn't Ordnance Chief?
  180. What if Lee and Forrest
  181. Destruction of Porter's Squadron before Vicksburg?
  182. What if Hooker was in command at Gettysburg?
  183. What if Lincoln had pulled the troops out of Ft. Sumter and Ft. Pickens?
  184. What if Beast Bulter was shot?
  185. What if Forrest had gotten control of the Army Of The Tennessee
  186. What if the Confederacy had won the War?
  187. Religion and the battlefield
  188. What if Lincoln had made a Non-Emancipation Proclamation?
  189. What if the Emancipation Proclamation had come from a different source?
  190. McDowell's success
  191. Confederate Capitol
  192. Fort Sumter
  193. What if Lincoln had LOST the 1860 election?
  194. One of the most popular "What If..." questions: Stonewall Jackson
  195. What if...Gettysburg/Vicksburg
  196. What if Robert E. Lee had not honorably surrendered?